Super Bowl 2023: Ranking each Chiefs and Eagles starter leading up to Super Bowl 57 matchup in Arizona – CBSSports.com

For every Super Bowl, I rank the 44 starters in the game to see if that can help get a gauge on where the game is heading. In the past, I’ve done 46 starters to include the nickel corners. But they are now full-fledged starters in the NFL, so the third linebacker isn’t getting graded as we prepare for Super Bowl LVII between the Chiefs and Eagles this Sunday in Glendale, Arizona.

Based on my analysis, the Kansas City Chiefs have the top stars but, on paper, in terms of my top-10 players, the game looks even. Each team has five players in my top 10, with the Chiefs having the top three.

Those three at the top are quarterback Patrick Mahomes, tight end Travis Kelce and defensive tackle Chris Jones. The Eagles‘ top-ranked player is center Jason Kelce, who is fourth on my list. That means the Kelce family has two of the top-four players in the game. That’s simply amazing.

If we dive deeper into the numbers, the Eagles have 12 of the top 20 players, with three of their offensive linemen in the top 14. They are Jason Kelce, right tackle Lane Johnson at No. 5 and left tackle Jordan Mailata at No. 15. The other two starters, guards Isaac Seumalo and Landon Dickerson are both inside the top 26 in the game, which shows just how good that line is for the Eagles.

While the Chiefs have Jones at No. 3 and pass rusher Frank Clark at No. 18 from their defensive line, the other two defensive line starters are at the bottom of the rankings. They are defensive tackle Derrick Nnadi and defensive end George Karlaftis. They both have to be better than they’ve played this season, with Nnadi needing to come up big against the run, if the Chiefs are to slow the Eagles. 

If the Eagles front vs. the Chiefs defensive line decides this game, the Eagles should win. But we know how stars can change that, which is why the Chiefs having the top three players in the game, including Mahomes, balances that out. The game is close to a pick ’em for a reason, at least according to the ranking of the players.

Ranking Super Bowl LVII starters



Patrick Mahomes


Kansas City Chiefs QB



Travis Kelce


Kansas City Chiefs TE



Chris Jones


Kansas City Chiefs DT



Jason Kelce


Philadelphia Eagles C



Lane Johnson


Philadelphia Eagles OT



Jalen Hurts


Philadelphia Eagles QB



Creed Humphrey


Kansas City Chiefs C



A.J. Brown


Philadelphia Eagles WR



Haason Reddick


Philadelphia Eagles OLB



Joe Thuney


Kansas City Chiefs OG



T.J. Edwards


Philadelphia Eagles MLB



Darius Slay


Philadelphia Eagles CB



James Bradberry


Philadelphia Eagles CB



Jordan Mailata


Philadelphia Eagles OT



DeVonta Smith


Philadelphia Eagles WR



L’Jarius Sneed


Kansas City Chiefs CB



Josh Sweat


Philadelphia Eagles DE



Frank Clark


Kansas City Chiefs DE



Dallas Goedert


Philadelphia Eagles TE



Trey Smith


Kansas City Chiefs OG



Javon Hargrave


Philadelphia Eagles NT



Trent McDuffie


Kansas City Chiefs CB



Isaac Seumalo


Philadelphia Eagles OG



Orlando Brown


Kansas City Chiefs OT



Juan Thornhill


Kansas City Chiefs FS



Landon Dickerson


Philadelphia Eagles OG



Miles Sanders


Philadelphia Eagles RB



Justin Reid


Kansas City Chiefs SS



JuJu Smith-Schuster


Kansas City Chiefs WR



Chauncey Gardner-Johnson


Philadelphia Eagles FS



Avonte Maddox


Philadelphia Eagles CB



Marquez Valdes-Scantling


Kansas City Chiefs WR



Isiah Pacheco


Kansas City Chiefs RB



Nick Bolton


Kansas City Chiefs MLB



Fletcher Cox


Philadelphia Eagles DE



Andrew Wylie


Kansas City Chiefs OT



Marcus Epps


Philadelphia Eagles SS



Willie Gay Jr.


Kansas City Chiefs OLB



Kyzir White


Philadelphia Eagles OLB



Kadarius Toney


Kansas City Chiefs WR



Jaylen Watson


Kansas City Chiefs CB



Quez Watkins


Philadelphia Eagles WR



George Karlaftis


Kansas City Chiefs DE



Derrick Nnadi


Kansas City Chiefs DT

User Input